Skip to content
Compare TV

If you liked it

Shows like Midnight Mass

24 shows like Midnight Mass (2021), with the reason each one made the list and where it streams in Australia today. 5 created by Mike Flanagan, 1 with the same lead cast and 3 with similar themes.

Shows
24
Streaming now
16
Free to stream
3

Where most of them stream

Netflix streams 10 of the 24 shows like Midnight Mass on this list. Add Prime Video and Paramount+ and you can stream 15 of them.

How many of these shows each service streams
ServiceShows
Netflix10
Prime Video4
BINGE1
Foxtel Now1
Paramount+1
10 Play1

We may earn a commission when you sign up through our links. How we make money.

24 shows like Midnight Mass, closest first

Tap a title for every place to watch it, the trailer and the cast. Save any of them to your list.

  1. 1. The Haunting of Hill House★ 8.6

    2018 · 1 season

    Created by Mike Flanagan

    The Crains, a fractured family, confront haunting memories of their old home and the terrifying events that drove them from it.

  2. 2. The Haunting of Bly Manor★ 7.4

    2020 · 1 season

    Created by Mike Flanagan

    After an au pair’s tragic death, Henry Wingrave hires a young American nanny to care for his orphaned niece and nephew who reside at Bly Manor with the estate’s chef Owen, groundskeeper Jamie and housekeeper, Mrs. Grose. But all is not as it seems at the manor, and centuries of dark secrets of love and loss are waiting to be unearthed in this chilling tale.

  3. 3. The Midnight Club★ 6.5

    2022 · 1 season

    Created by Mike Flanagan

    At a manor with a mysterious history, the 8 members of the Midnight Club meet each night at midnight to tell sinister stories - and to look for signs of the supernatural from the beyond.

    Stream it on

  4. 4. The Fall of the House of Usher

    2023 · 1 season

    Created by Mike Flanagan

    Ruthless siblings Roderick and Madeline Usher have built Fortunato Pharmaceuticals into an empire of wealth, privilege and power. But past secrets come to light when the heirs to the Usher dynasty start dying at the hands of a mysterious woman from their youth.

    Stream it on

  5. 5. Carrie

    2026 · 2 seasons

    Created by Mike Flanagan

    After her father's sudden, untimely death thrusts her into the unforgiving ecosystem of public high school, Carrie is forced to navigate a viral bullying scandal that tears through her community, the relentless pressure and casual cruelty of the social‑media age, and the awakening of mysterious telekinetic powers that rise alongside her adolescence.

  6. 6. Greenleaf

    2016 · 5 seasons

    Similar themes

    The unscrupulous world of the Greenleaf family and their sprawling Memphis megachurch, where scandalous secrets and lies are as numerous as the faithful. Born of the church, the Greenleaf family love and care for each other, but beneath the surface lies a den of iniquity-greed, adultery, sibling rivalry and conflicting values-that threatens to tear apart the very core of their faith that holds them together.

    Not on a streaming service in Australia right now. Buy it from $84.95 on the Apple TV store.

  7. 7. Horror's Greatest

    2024 · 2 seasons

    Also stars Kate Siegel

    A deep dive into everything we love about horror - from fresh looks at classics to unearthing scores of hidden gems, this series has something for every fright film enthusiast.

    Stream it on

    Shudder
  8. 8. Good Behavior

    2016 · 2 seasons

    Similar themes

    Letty Dobesh is a thief and con artist fresh out of prison whose life is always one wrong turn and bad decision from implosions - just how she likes it. But when she overhears a hitman being hired to kill a man’s wife, she sets out to derail the job, launching her on a collision course with the killer, entangling them in a dangerous and seductive relationship.

    Not on a streaming service in Australia right now. Buy it from $31.98 on the Apple TV store.

  1. 9. American Gods

    2017 · 3 seasons

    An ex-con becomes the traveling partner of a conman who turns out to be one of the older gods trying to recruit troops to battle the upstart deities. Based on Neil Gaiman's fantasy novel.

  2. 10. Fantasy Island

    1978 · 7 seasons

    Similar themes

    A magical island hosted by Mr Roarke and Tattoo where weekly guests learn valuable life lessons in their pursuit of fulfilling their dreams. Not all dreams are fulfilled as expected.

    Not on a streaming service in Australia right now. Buy it from $9.99 on the Apple TV store.

  3. 11. 7th Heaven

    1996 · 11 seasons

    Reverend Eric Camden and his wife Annie have always had their hands full caring for seven children, not to mention the friends, sweethearts and spouses that continually come and go in the Camden household.

    Not on a streaming service in Australia right now. Buy it from $274.89 on the Apple TV store.

  4. 12. The Thorn Birds

    1983 · 1 season

    The story based on a novel by Colleen McCullough focuses on three generations of the Cleary family living on a sheep station in the Australian outback.

    Not on a streaming service in Australia right now.

  5. 13. Pact of Silence

    2023 · 1 season

    A big-time social media influencer plunges headfirst into the lives of four women fueled by a thirst for the truth about her birth - and revenge.

    Stream it on

  6. 14. I Love Dick★ 6.3

    2016 · 1 season

    Adapted from the lauded feminist novel and set in a colorful academic community in Marfa, Texas, this is the story of a struggling married couple, Chris and Sylvere, and their obsession with a charismatic professor named Dick. Told in Rashomon-style shifts of POV, the series charts the unraveling of a marriage, the awakening of an artist and the deification of a reluctant messiah.

    Stream it (free on some)

  7. 15. I Woke Up a Vampire

    2023 · 2 seasons

    On her 13th birthday, Carmie discovers that she's actually half human, half vampire - and that mythical powers make middle school way more complicated.

    Stream it on

  8. 16. Why Women Kill★ 8.3

    2019 · 2 seasons

    Three women living in three different decades: a housewife in the '60s, a socialite in the '80s and a lawyer in 2018, deal with infidelity in their marriages.

  9. 17. Save Me

    2017 · 2 seasons

    Save Me drops us into random lives, mid-sentence. We get to know people through storylines that unravel with humour and pathos and a built-in ticking time bomb - that one of them at some point will be blindsided by a medical emergency. And all of it is rooted in the on-going stories of our regular cast of EMTs who come to the rescue.

    Not on a streaming service in Australia right now.

  10. 18. Utopia★ 6.7

    2020 · 1 season

    A group of young adults who met online are mercilessly hunted by a shadowy deep state organization after they come into possession of a near-mythical cult underground graphic novel.

  11. 19. Vampire Knight★ 7.3

    2008 · 2 seasons

    Yuki Cross, along with her best friend Zero, attempts to keep the peace between humans and vampires at Cross Academy, but personal issues soon threaten the situation.

    Stream it on

  12. 20. The Red Road★ 7.4

    2014 · 2 seasons

    Lines will be crossed when tragedy forces two men, a mesmerizing ex-con and an embattled local cop, to face the secrets of their past. As these two men find themselves increasingly compromised by one another, the lives of both quickly unravel.

    Not on a streaming service in Australia right now. Buy it from $29.98 on the Prime Video store.

  13. 21. Rev.★ 7.8

    2010 · 3 seasons

    Sitcom about a vicar running an inner-city church.

    Not on a streaming service in Australia right now. Buy it from $36.98 on the Apple TV store.

  14. 22. Castlevania: Nocturne

    2023 · 2 seasons

    In the thick of the French Revolution, members of the so-called lower classes are rising up to fight inequality. Meanwhile, Richter Belmont senses a far grimmer and greater danger. He's picked up his family's long-held tradition of vampire hunting, a vocation that goes back almost as long as a vampiric life span (in other words, forever) but he's never seen anything quite like what he's witnessing now.

    Stream it on

  15. 23. Mr. Mercedes★ 7.8

    2017 · 3 seasons

    A retired detective, tormented by a serial killer through a series of letters and emails, sets out on a dangerous and potentially illegal crusade.

    Stream it (free on some)

  16. 24. Turn of the Tide★ 7.5

    2023 · 2 seasons

    When a boat loaded with cocaine sinks off his home island, Eduardo sees a risky but exciting opportunity to make money and fulfill impossible dreams.

    Stream it on

Likeness: TMDB franchise, creator, cast and keyword facts. Where to watch: JustWatch daily feed for Australia, updated 18 November 2026. Ratings: IMDb.

More shows like your favourites

Frequently asked questions

What shows are like Midnight Mass?

The closest are The Haunting of Hill House, The Haunting of Bly Manor and The Midnight Club. This list has 24 shows like Midnight Mass, picked from what they share with it: 5 created by Mike Flanagan, 1 with the same lead cast and 3 with similar themes.

Where can I stream shows like Midnight Mass in Australia?

16 of the 24 stream in Australia today. Netflix has the most (10, including The Haunting of Hill House, The Haunting of Bly Manor and The Midnight Club), then Prime Video with 4, BINGE with 1 and Foxtel Now with 1.

Can I watch any shows like Midnight Mass for free?

Yes: American Gods, I Love Dick and Mr. Mercedes stream free in Australia, on a free app or with ads.

How are these shows picked?

From TMDB facts about each title: the same franchise, the same creators, the same lead cast, and the less common story keywords they share. Where to watch comes from the JustWatch daily feed for Australia.

Where to watch Midnight Mass in Australia