S05E04Are You Afraid of the Dark? · Season 5
Are You Afraid of the Dark? season 5 episode 4: The Tale of the Mystical Mirror
S05E04Aired 11 November 199524 min
Where to watch Are You Afraid of the Dark? Season 5 in Australia
We could not find Are You Afraid of the Dark? season 5 on any streaming, free or buy service in Australia right now.
We refresh this every day, so check back soon.
Availability checked 18 November 2026.
Rate Are You Afraid of the Dark? S05E04
How was it? Your stars go into the CompareTV readers' score for this episode and mark it watched in your Up next. Free, and your email is never shown.
CompareTV readers
Be the first to rate it
The readers' score shows from 3 ratings.
What happens in “The Tale of the Mystical Mirror”
Employees from a boutique are disappearing and no one knows why. Soon after getting a job there, Cindy discovers the truth. Mrs. Valenti, the owner, is really centuries old and using her youthful employees to stay young.
Episode summary: TMDB.
Before you watch
- It is episode 4 of 13 of season 5, so watch episodes 1 to 3 first.
- It runs about 24 minutes.
Cast and crew of this episode
- Guest stars
- Laura Bertram as LaurelLexi Randall as CindyJayne Heitmeyer as Ms. ValentiGenevieve Ferderber as TannisAndrea Lui as VickiBabs Gadbois as Old Ms. Valent
Credits: TMDB.
More from Are You Afraid of the Dark? Season 5
Previous · S05E03The Tale of Station 109.14 November 1995
Next · S05E05The Tale of Prisoners Past2 December 1995Every episode of Season 5Are You Afraid of the Dark? episode guide
Episode names, air dates, runtimes, stills and ratings: TMDB. Air dates are the first broadcast anywhere; where it streams is our daily Australian check.

Discuss Are You Afraid of the Dark? S05E04
Community rulesSpoilers for this episode are fair game here, so tag them: tick “Spoiler” or wrap words in
||double bars||.Season 5 discussionWhole show discussion
Join the discussion
Free, one field: we email you a sign-in link. People see the name you pick, never your email.
Or continue with GoogleNo one has said a word yet.
Start the discussion of S05E04: the best moment, the twist you saw coming, the one you did not.