Smile for the Dead: An Examination of Spirit Photography (2025)

Review Team

4/5

Smile for the Dead: An Examination of Spirit Photography is a compelling historical drama that takes a fascinating look at the life of William H Mumler, a figure at the centre of a sensational trial in 1869. The film is meticulously crafted, with Hamilton Young Ward's direction bringing to life the ... Show more >> Smile for the Dead: An Examination of Spirit Photography is a compelling historical drama that takes a fascinating look at the life of William H Mumler, a figure at the centre of a sensational trial in 1869. The film is meticulously crafted, with Hamilton Young Ward's direction bringing to life the eerie atmosphere of a society grappling with the unknown. The performances are particularly noteworthy, with the lead actor portraying Mumler's complex motivations with depth and nuance. The cinematography captures the haunting beauty of the era, while the narrative raises essential questions about belief, fraud, and the human desire to connect with the deceased. Though the pacing may feel slow at times, the film ultimately rewards patient viewers with its rich themes and thought-provoking conclusions. It is a must-watch for those interested in the intersection of history and the supernatural. Show less

Editor Team

3/5

If you're in the mood for something a bit different, Smile for the Dead: An Examination of Spirit Photography might just pique your interest. This film takes us back to 1869, where William H Mumler is on trial for fraud, accused of faking spirit photographs. It's an intriguing premise, and while the ... Show more >> If you're in the mood for something a bit different, Smile for the Dead: An Examination of Spirit Photography might just pique your interest. This film takes us back to 1869, where William H Mumler is on trial for fraud, accused of faking spirit photographs. It's an intriguing premise, and while the film is visually striking, it sometimes feels like it gets lost in its own ponderousness. The dialogue can be a bit stilted, and not every emotional beat lands as effectively as intended. That said, it does a decent job of exploring the thin line between belief and deception. If you're a fan of historical dramas with a supernatural twist, this film is worth a watch, but don't expect a fast-paced thriller. It's more of a slow burn that invites contemplation rather than immediate thrills. Show less