講話沒有在聽 (2021)

Review Team

4/5

講話沒有在聽 is a poignant exploration of life, death, and the enduring bonds of family. Directed by Nyssa Li, the film presents a unique narrative where Jhong observes his family coping with his death. The performances are heartfelt, especially from the lead, who captures the essence of a man caught betw ... Show more >> 講話沒有在聽 is a poignant exploration of life, death, and the enduring bonds of family. Directed by Nyssa Li, the film presents a unique narrative where Jhong observes his family coping with his death. The performances are heartfelt, especially from the lead, who captures the essence of a man caught between worlds. The breakfast scene serves as a brilliant metaphor for communication beyond the grave, highlighting the unspoken thoughts that linger after loss. The cinematography is understated yet effective, allowing the emotional weight of the story to shine through. While the pacing may feel slow at times, the film rewards its viewers with a profound reflection on love and remembrance. Overall, 講話沒有在聽 is a touching film that urges audiences to appreciate the fleeting nature of life. Show less

Editor Team

3/5

講話沒有在聽 is an intriguing concept that unfortunately stumbles in execution. The premise of a deceased man watching his family navigate their grief has potential, but the film sometimes feels drawn out and lacks tension. While the performances are commendable, particularly from the wife character who c ... Show more >> 講話沒有在聽 is an intriguing concept that unfortunately stumbles in execution. The premise of a deceased man watching his family navigate their grief has potential, but the film sometimes feels drawn out and lacks tension. While the performances are commendable, particularly from the wife character who conveys her emotions beautifully, the overall impact is diluted by a slow narrative pace. Some scenes evoke genuine emotion, yet others feel repetitive. The direction by Nyssa Li is competent, but I wished for a bit more flair to keep the audience engaged. It’s a film that has its moments but may leave some viewers yearning for a more dynamic storytelling approach. If you enjoy contemplative films about loss, it might still be worth a watch, but manage your expectations. Show less