The Big Cigar (2024)

Review Team

4/5

The Big Cigar presents a fascinating intersection of history and Hollywood, showcasing the unlikely alliance between Huey P. Newton and Bert Schneider. The film is anchored by strong performances, particularly from the lead actors, who bring depth to their complex characters. The narrative flows wel ... Show more >> The Big Cigar presents a fascinating intersection of history and Hollywood, showcasing the unlikely alliance between Huey P. Newton and Bert Schneider. The film is anchored by strong performances, particularly from the lead actors, who bring depth to their complex characters. The narrative flows well, moving between tense moments of evasion and quieter, more introspective scenes that explore the characters' motivations. The direction is both thoughtful and engaging, allowing the audience to reflect on the broader implications of their journey. Overall, The Big Cigar is a thought-provoking film that shines a light on a pivotal moment in history while maintaining a personal touch. Show less

Editor Team

3/5

While The Big Cigar has its moments of brilliance, it occasionally stumbles under the weight of its ambitious narrative. The film starts strong, with an intriguing premise and rich characterisation. However, as it progresses, certain pacing issues emerge, making some scenes feel drawn out. The chemi ... Show more >> While The Big Cigar has its moments of brilliance, it occasionally stumbles under the weight of its ambitious narrative. The film starts strong, with an intriguing premise and rich characterisation. However, as it progresses, certain pacing issues emerge, making some scenes feel drawn out. The chemistry between Newton and Schneider is palpable, but at times, their interactions lack the urgency one might expect from a high-stakes escape. The cinematography captures the era well, yet the film could have benefited from a tighter edit to maintain momentum. Despite its flaws, The Big Cigar is still a worthwhile watch for those interested in historical dramas. Show less