Girls State (2024)

Review Team

4/5

Girls State presents a compelling portrait of young women grappling with the complexities of democracy. The documentary immerses viewers in the lives of its subjects, showcasing their diverse backgrounds and the earnestness with which they approach the task of government-building. The film’s structu ... Show more >> Girls State presents a compelling portrait of young women grappling with the complexities of democracy. The documentary immerses viewers in the lives of its subjects, showcasing their diverse backgrounds and the earnestness with which they approach the task of government-building. The film’s structure allows for moments of tension and camaraderie, illustrating the challenges and triumphs these teens face. Director Amanda McBaine and Jesse Moss skillfully capture the emotional depth of their subjects, making each character relatable and inspiring. The cinematography is engaging, with dynamic editing that keeps the pace brisk. Overall, Girls State is a thought-provoking film that not only entertains but also encourages reflection on real-world political engagement. Show less

Editor Team

3/5

Girls State has an intriguing premise: teenage girls forming their own government. However, while the concept is rich with potential, the execution sometimes feels uneven. The film showcases passionate young women, but it occasionally drifts into predictable territory, leaving some emotional arcs un ... Show more >> Girls State has an intriguing premise: teenage girls forming their own government. However, while the concept is rich with potential, the execution sometimes feels uneven. The film showcases passionate young women, but it occasionally drifts into predictable territory, leaving some emotional arcs underexplored. The raw energy of the girls is infectious, yet the film could have benefitted from a deeper dive into the political ideologies at play. That said, it does spark important conversations about leadership and representation. If you're interested in youth activism, Girls State is worth a watch, but it may not fully satisfy those seeking a more profound exploration of its themes. Show less