One Night in Idaho: The College Murders (2025)

Review Team

3.5/5

One Night in Idaho: The College Murders presents a gripping narrative that unfolds within the confines of a college plagued by a series of mysterious deaths. The film's pacing keeps the audience engaged, with moments of suspense that are both thrilling and thought-provoking. The performances, partic ... Show more >> One Night in Idaho: The College Murders presents a gripping narrative that unfolds within the confines of a college plagued by a series of mysterious deaths. The film's pacing keeps the audience engaged, with moments of suspense that are both thrilling and thought-provoking. The performances, particularly by the lead investigator, are commendable, bringing depth to their character's motivations and struggles. The direction is competent, yet at times, the film feels bogged down by its own ambition. While it delivers on tension and intrigue, some plot points may leave viewers questioning the overall coherence of the story. Ultimately, it is a solid addition to the genre, appealing to those who appreciate crime dramas with a psychological twist. Show less

Editor Team

4/5

One Night in Idaho: The College Murders is a captivating film that pulls you right into its dark and twisted world. From the moment the first death occurs, you’re hooked and left guessing until the very end. The film shines with strong performances that breathe life into a script filled with intrigu ... Show more >> One Night in Idaho: The College Murders is a captivating film that pulls you right into its dark and twisted world. From the moment the first death occurs, you’re hooked and left guessing until the very end. The film shines with strong performances that breathe life into a script filled with intrigue and unexpected turns. The atmosphere is thick with tension, expertly crafted by the director, who knows just when to reveal enough to keep you on your toes. While the narrative occasionally dips into familiar territory, it manages to rise above with its unique setting and character depth. This film is a must-watch for anyone who loves a good mystery that keeps you guessing. Grab some popcorn and prepare for a thrilling ride! Show less