The Idaho Student Murders (2025)

Review Team

4/5

The Idaho Student Murders presents a chilling dramatization of a tragic real-life event that has resonated with audiences. Directed by Catharine Park, the film captures the suspense and horror surrounding the brutal killings of four University of Idaho students. The narrative is tightly woven, focus ... Show more >> The Idaho Student Murders presents a chilling dramatization of a tragic real-life event that has resonated with audiences. Directed by Catharine Park, the film captures the suspense and horror surrounding the brutal killings of four University of Idaho students. The narrative is tightly woven, focusing on the accused, Bryan Kohberger, whose character is portrayed with depth and complexity. The performances are commendable, particularly from the lead, who brings a nuanced portrayal of a troubled genius. Park’s direction emphasises the emotional weight of the story while maintaining a gripping pace. The cinematography enhances the eerie atmosphere, immersing viewers in the unsettling reality of the crime. While the film is not without its flaws, particularly in pacing during certain sections, it effectively raises questions about morality, justice, and the impact of violence on a community. Overall, The Idaho Student Murders is a compelling watch for those interested in true crime narratives, offering both thrills and thought-provoking themes. Show less

Editor Team

3/5

The Idaho Student Murders tries to tackle a sensitive and horrific topic, but the execution leaves something to be desired. While it’s clear that the filmmakers aimed to create a gripping true crime thriller, the film sometimes feels more like a sensationalised retelling rather than a thoughtful exp ... Show more >> The Idaho Student Murders tries to tackle a sensitive and horrific topic, but the execution leaves something to be desired. While it’s clear that the filmmakers aimed to create a gripping true crime thriller, the film sometimes feels more like a sensationalised retelling rather than a thoughtful exploration of the real-life tragedy. The performances, particularly from the lead actor, are solid, but the script occasionally falls into clichés that detract from the emotional impact of the story. The direction by Catharine Park has its moments of brilliance, especially in the atmospheric scenes that evoke genuine fear, but there are also stretches where the pacing drags. The film’s attempt to delve into the psychology behind the crime is admirable, yet it often skims the surface instead of diving deep. For viewers who are fans of true crime dramas, The Idaho Student Murders may still offer some suspenseful moments, but it may not fully satisfy those looking for a profound narrative. It’s a decent film, but it could have been so much more. Show less